Sunday, 11 March 2012

green and red hats suit me best.

When we were asked to complete a wiki activity I initially thought ‘eep’, what in the world is a wiki? But like all 'unknown' technologies I encounter (especially of late) I managed to suss it out and was soon engaging in the Edward de Bono 6 Thinking Hat activity on mobile phones and thinking about whether or not they should be used in the classroom.


The activity coincided with our readings on learning theories in education. Behaviourism, cognitivism, connectivism and constructivism were explored. 
The question arose, which of the theories were applied in the Wiki activity? I could now establish that overall structure was built around the constructivism theory, with a hint of cognitive and connectivism.

What are the characteristics of the wiki design that lead you to that understanding?

Constructivists view learning as the result of mental construction (Ways of Learning, 2009).

The wiki is a social tool with an interactive scaffold design as its main characteristic.

This encouraged students to gain higher order thinking skills by putting on the hats and forming opinions based on prior knowledge, perceptions, experiences and skills. Therefore the comments displayed were a result of constructivism where students created new knowledge from their existing knowledge.


The wiki implemented a small element of the Cognitive theory. Mental processes such as thinking, memory, knowing, and problem-solving need to be explored (Learning Theories,2012). The 6 coloured hats placed in individual rows helped us map out our thought processes in order to achieve concise results.


Acknowledging the wiki as an an e-learning tool incorperates the Connectivism theory, a new theory described as a learning theory for the digital age Siemens (2008). I believe connectivism shares a role alongside the theories already mentioned as it focuses on online social networking of individuals collaborating to enhance learning. Siemens (2004), describes this as a community. 'A community is the clustering of similar areas of interest that allows for interaction, sharing, dialoguing and thinking together.' Connectivism partners with constructivism in the wiki activity as it encouraged us to think individually then collaborate socially. Theorist, Kerr explains the importance of connectivism's not losing 'the lessons of constructivism and the need for each learner to construct his or her own mental models in an individualistic way' (Forster, 2007).


In contrast these theories differ greatly from Behaviourism. This theory is described as teacher-centred because it focuses on the teacher's active role as a dispenser of knowledge, together with the use of teacher proof-resources and classroom materials (Literacy for the 21st Century, 2012). Due to the lack of teacher involvement and the freedom of the task it is fair to say that this is not a behaviourism theory activity.

Reflection
After a brief lesson on De Bono I joined my virtual wiki group and tried using various coloured hats, exploring my perceptions determined by the colour hat I had used. As a result I felt quite strongly about the issue of mobiles in the classroom. My opinions screamed out 'let the kids have their phones because they are an effective learning tool that we shouldn't ignore'. However, I think mobiles should be monitored and used only when applicable to the lesson.
My thoughts on the design of the activity were positive. I found the wiki to be user-friendly and a great way to work collaboratively with our class mates. During the ICT collaborating session the issue of comments being edited and potentially deleted by accident was brought up. In our group the yellow hat image mysteriously disappeared but it didn't affect the task in anyway, it was pretty smooth sailing.
Must note for future reference - when using wikis save a backup copy in a work doc.

How did the scaffold support the collection of a range of perspectives?
The scaffolding of the wiki task supported our learning by segregating perspectives into 6 different categories. The design was visually appealing with the comment area conveniently next to the coloured de-bono hats so the participants could clearly read what each hat was asking, think about the topic and make comments directly into the provided sections.
We then highlighted our opinions in a unique colour to display a diversity of comments by individuals.
This framework enhanced the learning experience for me because it forced me to think about the question in different perspectives. Initially I was inclined to turn my nose up at the opposing opinions. I know-I know, that wouldn't be the aim of the activity would it? So I plonked on the other hats and read through other perceptions which left me questioning my own judgements. It was an effective tool for me to appreciate alternative views.

For interest’s sake I then created a mind map by highlighting the main points from each hat to gain a clearer sense of the views within the debate. 

            Mind Map – Student '6 thinking hats' response to Mobile phones in the classroom


What are the benefits, issues, drawbacks of participating in a wiki like this?
So how did this student-centred activity enhance our learning and were there any drawbacks?

Wait while I put on my blue hat...
The wiki activity was a positive experience because:
  • It allowed time to reflect on the question individually and prepare a response before collaborating
  • The de bono hats encouraged a range of perceptions that may have not ordinary be investigated
  • It produced responses from a varied learning group (visual, verbal, active, reflective, intuitive, sensing, sequential and global)
  • It was a simple effective tool
  • It enhanced my understanding of a successful TPACK framework task
I'll just pop on my black hat.
The wiki's negative aspects may include:
  • Responses may have influenced others, stopping them from discovering their own responses
  • Learners may struggle with little teacher guidance (non-behaviourism).
  • Some may not know how to use a wiki
  • May become overwhelmed with the strong opinions and amount to read
  • High achievers could do all the work for the group (while some may sit back)
  • Comments could be edited or accidentally deleted

How would it contribute to the learning of your students?
The wiki is an innovative tool which encourages students to think individually then collaboratively as a team. The social element gives students the opportunity to use their initiative and not be reliant on teacher guidelines.

I love the idea of the 6 thinking hats and jumped onto ebay to order a book straight away.
I would incorporate de bono's in the curriculum as a support for students to discuss, respond and analyse authentic tasks and issues concerning them.
For example, student could:
  • analyse blogs: artistic components and social responsibilities
  • discuss facebook and the implications on online bullying
  • discuss the pros and cons of graffiti
  • reflect on artists' work and their own ideas
  • share feelings on a school art exhibition
  • analyse the impact of movie ratings and whether students follow these guidelines
  • discuss the issues of music videos influencing teenagers
De Bonos 6 thinking hats could assist me with my teaching strategies, allowing me think in a range of perspectives and identify teaching methods that will enhance students learning experiences.

In saying that, why not use it for personal choices? Peanut butter on my toast today? Too fatty? High in fibre? But it tastes good...Problem solved.

References:
Pritchard, A. (2009). Ways of Learning. Cognitive, constructivist learning.

Oxford University Press, (March 2011) Connectivism, A theory of Learning for a Digital Age.
http://oupeltglobalblog.com/2011/03/30/connectivism-a-theory-of-learning-for-a-digital-age/

Kop,R. Hill,A. (2008), International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, Vol 9, No3. Connectivism: Learning theory of the future or vestige of the past?
http://www.cqu.edu.au/library


Tompkins, Campbell and Green 2012, 'Literacy for the 21st Century: a balanced approach

Learning Theories Knowledgebase, (march 2012)
http://www.learning-theories.com


No comments:

Post a Comment